Rob Edwards

John Ainslie 1954-2016

from The Guardian, 2 November 2016

In 1992, when the first submarine armed with Trident nuclear missiles arrived on the Clyde near Glasgow, John Ainslie was in a canoe. Along with a flotilla of other protesters, he was buzzing the huge dark boat as it cut through the cold water. He had just been appointed as the coordinator of the Scottish Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament (SCND), and he was arrested by the Ministry of Defence police.

John, who has died of cancer aged 62, was the quiet, unassuming heart of the peace movement in Scotland for the last 25 years. As well as putting himself on the line, he became an authoritative and internationally respected nuclear researcher. He was the author of 20 reports on aspects of nuclear policy, starting in 1992 with Cracking Under Pressure, about defects in nuclear submarine reactors.

His most recent report, in July, written with Dan Plesch from the University of London, argued that successive UK governments had deceived the public by pretending that Trident was a British bomb when it is actually American. Other reports exposed Trident’s safety flaws, its targeting strategies, and its secret workings. In 2008, he discovered problems with a mysterious top-secret warhead ingredient known as fogbank.

He backed Scottish independence as a way of triggering UK nuclear disarmament. In the run-up to the referendum in 2014 he showed how Trident warheads could be removed from the Clyde within two years – and how they could not safely be based anywhere else in the UK.

John played a crucial role in breaking the story of the Trident submariner, William McNeilly, who went on the run in 2015 after alleging 30 safety and security flaws. John was a skilled user of freedom of information law, and helped to prise open the MoD’s secretive nuclear citadel and expose its inadequacies.

Astute submarines plagued by 69 safety incidents over four years

from Sunday Herald, 21 February 2016

The Royal Navy’s new nuclear-powered submarines have been plagued by 69 safety incidents and “near misses” over the last four years, the Ministry of Defence (MoD) has disclosed.

The Astute class of submarines based at Faslane on the Clyde has seen reported reactor incidents at sea or on shore almost double from 12 in 2014 to 21 in 2015. Though the MoD insists that the incidents are all minor, critics warn that they undermine the boats’ reliability and safety.

The first submarine of the class, HMS Astute, has already been out on operations, and the second, HMS Ambush, was launched in 2011. The third, HMS Artful, was formally handed over the Royal Navy in December 2015.

The four remaining Astute submarines are either still being built by the defence firm BAE Systems at its Barrow shipyard, or are due to be built there. The construction programme has been subject to a series of delays and cost overruns.

The MoD revealed the number of safety events recorded with Astute submarine reactors between January 2012 and January 2016 in response to a request under freedom of information law. There were an average of more than 17 a year, or one every three weeks (see table below).

Concerns over safety at Rosyth after emergency exercise failures

from Sunday Herald, 10 January 2016

The safety regime at the Rosyth naval dockyard in Fife has been called into question after an emergency exercise failed to demonstrate adequate arrangements for rescuing casualties from an accident.

The UK government’s nuclear safety watchdog has ordered Babcock, the multinational company that runs the dockyard for the Royal Navy, to rerun the exercise, codenamed Nightstar, in March because of mistakes made last September.

An inspection by the Office for Nuclear Regulation (ONR) concluded that there were flaws in the way that staff looked after injured people during the exercise. There were also communication and command problems in dealing with the imagined accident.

The revelation has prompted “unease” about safety at the naval base, according to the local MP. Anti-nuclear campaigners have highlighted the serious risks of accidents, and demanded higher standards.

The problems with the Nightstar exercise on 30 September 2015 were disclosed in the ONR’s latest three-monthly report on Rosyth, posted online. Though inspectors thought that some of the exercise procedures were adequate, others were not.

Scottish shellfish are contaminated by radioactive waste from Sellafield

from Sunday Herald, 20 December 2015

Radioactive waste from the Sellafield nuclear plant in Cumbria is contaminating shellfish hundreds of kilometres away on the west coast of Scotland, according to a new scientific study.

Scottish researchers discovered traces of radioactive carbon discharged from Sellafield in the shells of mussels, cockles and winkles as far north as Port Appin in Argyll, 256 kilometres from the notorious nuclear plant.

The findings are a “wake-up call” for anyone who thinks pollution from Sellafield is yesterday’s problem, say campaigners. Sellafield, however, stresses that the contamination is well below safety limits.

The study was carried out by a team of scientists from the Scottish Universities Environmental Research Centre in East Kilbride and the Scottish Association for Marine Science in Oban. It has been published online in the Journal of Environmental Radioactivity.

The scientists found raised levels of radioactive carbon-14 in shellfish sampled at Port Appin, at Maidens in South Ayrshire and at Garlieston and Kippford on the Solway coast of Dumfries and Galloway. Mussels were most contaminated “due to the surface environment they inhabit and their feeding behaviour,” they said.

Trident missile flaw could trigger radioactive disaster, says leaked MoD report

from Sunday Herald, 24 May 2015

An inherent flaw in Trident missiles could lead to fires, explosions and widespread radioactive contamination, according to a top-secret safety manual leaked by the naval whistleblower, William McNeilly.

The Royal Navy’s official instructions on how to take care of nuclear weapons reveal that the “chief potential hazard” from a live missile is the “accidental ignition” of solid rocket fuel. This could cause the warheads’ conventional high explosives to detonate and scatter plutonium and other toxic materials “over a wide area”, it says.

The Trident D5 missile, used by both the UK and the US, is designed with nuclear warheads closely wrapped around the third stage rocket motor. This has been highlighted as a design flaw by US experts in the past, but has not previously been acknowledged by the Ministry of Defence (MoD). 

The results of a rocket fuel fire at sea or on land could be “catastrophic” for submariners and the public, critics warned last night. The MoD, however, said it had to train for every scenario “no matter how extreme and unlikely”. 

McNeilly, as well as alleging 30 Trident security and safety concerns in an 18-page dossier revealed by the Sunday Herald last weekend, says he filmed the weapons safety manual on his smart phone. Codenamed CB8890, it is a book kept in a safe in submarine missile control centre, he says.

Extracts quoted by McNeilly disclose that the warheads “clustered around the third stage rocket motor are at risk from a rocket motor propellant fire”. Exposed to heat, the warheads’ conventional high explosives “could cook to (non-nuclear) detonation, releasing radioactive materials and aerosols over a wide area,” the manual says.

If warhead containment is breached, “several radioactive and/or toxic materials may be exposed to the atmosphere,” it says. “These include plutonium, uranium, lithium compounds, tritium gas and beryllium. If mixed with water, fumes or toxic gases will be generated.”

MoD under pressure on Trident whistleblower’s fate

from Sunday Herald, 24 May 2015

McNeilly snapped in Portsmouth

While the Trident whistleblower, William McNeilly, was being mysteriously moved around Britain last week, a massive nuclear bomb convoy trundled along some of Scotland’s busiest roads. 

Although the Ministry of Defence (MoD) would rather have kept the movements of both the man and the weapons secret, they were defeated by social media. A fellow sailor posted a photograph of McNeilly in the canteen of Nelson barracks in Portsmouth, while members of the public tweeted when they saw the convoy of more than 20 vehicles driving by Stirling and Edinburgh.

The MoD is coming under mounting pressure to explain the fate of McNeilly, the naval nuclear weapons technician who alleged 30 safety and security flaws on Trident submarines. A defence minister is expected to make a statement to the House of Commons in London on Thursday.

That same evening the SNP’s former First Minister, Alex Salmond MP, has secured a debate on McNeilly’s allegations in the House of Commons, which will oblige ministers to answer further questions. MoD attempts to “brush it all under the carpet” were “profoundly unsatisfactory”, Salmond declared.

The Sunday Herald broke the McNeilly story while he was on the run abroad last weekend. On Monday evening he surrendered himself to the naval police at Edinburgh airport, but the MoD has refused to say where he has since been held, or how he might be punished.

I'll be handing myself in to the police today, says Trident whistleblower

18 May 2016

The nuclear weapons technician on the run since he blew the whistle on 30 alleged safety and security flaws on Trident submarines has said that he is going to give himself up to police today.

In a new public post on Facebook just after 1pm, William McNeilly (25) said that had achieved what he wanted. "I set out to gather as much information as possible, as fast as possible, inform you and the government before getting caught, then hand myself into the police," he said.

"I will be handing myself into the police today." Trident was "a broken system", he claimed. "If you continue to defend it sooner or later more truth will come out or a catastrophe will happen."

The Scottish Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament has this afternoon launched a petition to pardon McNeilly. "He should be commended for exposing the poor safety standards on nuclear submarines and not persecuted," it says.

McNeilly accused the Royal Navy of playing down his 18-page dossier alleging fire risks, leaks, a flood and security breaches on the submarines that carry Britain's nuclear weapons. The navy has said his report contains "subjective and unsubstantiated personal views, made by a very junior sailor, with which the naval service completely disagrees."

He said: "Responding by downplaying a report because there’s lack of seniority, acting like your security system is impenetrable and your aged system is still in excellent condition for sailing, is not an adequate response. Anyone who can use simple logic will not believe that."

Trident whistleblower says he will give himself up

from The National, 18 May 2015

The nuclear weapons engineer on the run after he blew the whistle on 30 alleged safety and security flaws plaguing Trident submarines has told his family he’s planning to give himself up.

Royal Navy submariner, William McNeilly (25), assured his brother on Facebook yesterday that he was “relatively safe now” though he couldn’t say where he was. “I will return to the UK and hand myself in soon,” he said.

“I may be alone physically, but I'm backed by a growing army. Change is coming. Don't worry about me,” he added. “This is about doing what I swore to do: protect the people and the land against threats both foreign and domestic.”

The Royal Navy has launched an investigation into McNeilly’s allegations, and says it “is working closely with civilian police to locate him”. Anti-nuclear campaigners yesterday praised his bravery, and urged the Navy not to hound him.

McNeilly, from Newtownabbey in Belfast, joined the Navy in July 2013 and served on patrol with the Trident submarine, HMS Victorious, from January to April this year. He went absent without leave last week, after writing a dramatic and damning account of the multiple problems he says he saw or heard about.

Trident is a disaster waiting to happen, says nuclear whistleblower

from Sunday Herald, 17 May 2015

Trident submarines are plagued by serious security lapses, beset by multiple safety blunders and “a disaster waiting to happen”, according to a nuclear weapons engineer turned whistleblower now being hunted by the police.

William McNeilly, who says he was on patrol with HMS Victorious from January to April this year, alleges that the Trident missiles it carries are vulnerable to a terrorist attack that “would kill our people and destroy our land.” Infiltrators have “the perfect opportunity to send nuclear warheads crashing down on the UK”, he claims.

He has written a detailed 18-page report called ‘The Nuclear Secrets’ claiming to lift the lid on the alarming state of the UK’s ageing and short-staffed nuclear deterrent. He went absent without leave from the Royal Navy last week, is on the run and expects to be arrested.

“This is bigger than me, it’s bigger than all of us,” he says. “We are so close to a nuclear disaster it is shocking, and yet everybody is accepting the risk to the public. If we don’t act now lives could be lost for generations.”

The risk was “extremely high”, he told the Sunday Herald. “My information comes from good sources and I have no reason to lie. If change isn’t made, a nuclear catastrophe almost certainly will happen.”

McNeilly’s report alleges 30 safety and security flaws on Trident submarines, based at Faslane on the Clyde. They include failures testing whether missiles could be safely launched, burning toilet rolls starting a fire in a missile compartment, and security passes and bags going unchecked.

He also reports alarms being muted because they went off so often, missile safety procedures being ignored and top secret information left unguarded. “It's just a matter of time before we're infiltrated by a psychopath or a terrorist,” he says. “There were some people that I served with on that patrol, who showed clear psychopathic tendencies.”

Edited extract from Nuclear Secrets by William McNeilly

from Sunday Herald, 17 May 2015

My name is William McNeilly. I am a weapons engineer submariner for the UK's Trident II D5 strategic weapons system. The penalty for releasing this report will be life prison if I’m lucky.

The worst fear for me isn’t prison or being assassinated, it’s the fear of sacrificing everything I have just to warn the public and yet never be heard. My leave expires today. I will be hunted down for not turning up.

When I’m found I will confess and will no longer be able to keep trying to warn the public. This document will enlighten you about the shockingly extreme conditions that our nuclear weapons system is in right now, and has been in the past. I need you to publish this document or send it to someone who will - please, for the safety of the people.

The complete lack of concern for security worries me. The fact is it would have been even easier for me to cause a nuclear catastrophe than to gather information, and gathering information was actually quite simple, due to the amount of ignorance.

We are at war, with a new kind of enemy. The terrorists have infiltrated every nation on our planet. Our nuclear weapons are a target that's wide open to attack. You don't have to be Alexander the Great to see we must adapt our strategies.

The Cold War is over; are we still in situation where we must invest billions upon billions into a system that puts our citizens at risk? No! We must adapt to the evolving world in order to survive!

I had envisioned a system with strict security and safety. I didn't see how wrong I was until I arrived at HMS Neptune (Faslane). At the gate the guard barely looked at my pass. It's harder to get into most nightclubs.

We headed down the boat. No search at all. It wasn't because we're Royal Navy personnel; it was because that's the standard procedures. Hundreds of contractors go down the boat when it's alongside. Their equipment isn't searched and they are not patted down. All it takes is someone to bring a bomb on board to commit the worst terrorist attack the UK and the world has ever seen.

Nuclear waste safety limits relaxed at Sellafield after accident

from The Guardian, 14 May 2015

Safety limits on the storage of some of the world’s most dangerous nuclear wastes at Sellafield in Cumbria have been relaxed after an accident knocked out a treatment plant and caused “gross contamination”.

The government’s safety watchdog, the Office for Nuclear Regulation (ONR), has permitted the private company that runs Sellafield to breach legal restrictions on the amount of hot, high-level radioactive waste that can be kept in tanks. The limits are likely to be exceeded by up to 350 tonnes between April 2014 and July 2016.

Critics accused ONR of breaking their promises and putting Sellafield’s profits before safety. But ONR insisted there was “minimal hazard increase”, while Sellafield said it put safety first.

The waste storage limits, imposed in 2001, were meant to reduce stocks to below 5,500 tonnes of uranium equivalent by July 2015. The aim was to minimise the risk of a disaster spreading a plume of potentially lethal radioactive contamination over the UK and Ireland – officially regarded as Sellafield’s “worst credible accident”.

The liquid waste comes from Britain’s nuclear power stations and generates significant amounts of heat. It has to be constantly cooled and stirred to prevent it from overheating.

Sellafield asked for permission to breach the storage limits to help cope with a backlog caused by an accident in November 2013. A plant meant to solidify the waste to make it safer lost power, suffered "gross contamination” and had to be closed for 11 months.

Devonport naval dockyard under fire for nuclear safety breaches

Exclusive, 22 April 2015

A government watchdog has reprimanded the Royal Navy’s nuclear submarine base at Devonport in Plymouth after a string of safety breaches.

The Office for Nuclear Regulation (ONR) has served the base with a legal enforcement notice to remedy flaws in the arrangements for protecting workers from radiation. It has also disclosed five incidents in which safety rules were broken between October and December last year, and described the procedures for reporting incidents as "significantly below standard".

Devonport is the largest naval base in Western Europe, and services Britain’s nuclear submarine fleet. One of the submarines usually armed with Trident nuclear missiles, HMS Vengeance, is currently being refitted there, with another, HMS Vanguard, due in next for maintenance.

Because of concerns over health and safety, the base has been given “an enhanced level of regulatory attention” by ONR since 2013. An incident last year in which a worker was contaminated with radioactivity prompted ONR to issue a statutory improvement notice in December. 

Though the radiation dose the worker received was small, ONR said it “highlighted shortfalls in the health and safety arrangements for working with ionising radiations at Devonport Royal Dockyard”. The dockyard has been ordered “to bring the arrangements up to an acceptable standard” before the end of January 2016.

Work on new Trident for the Clyde begins before Westminster decides

from Sunday Herald, 12 April 2015

The Ministry of Defence (MoD) has begun work on stationing new Trident submarines on the Clyde before the UK parliament has decided whether or not to give them the go-ahead, the Sunday Herald can reveal.

The MoD has launched a series of studies into how the Faslane and Coulport naval bases can accommodate larger “successor” submarines to replace the four existing Trident boats. But the decision on whether they will be needed is not due to be taken until next year by the MPs that will be elected next month.

The revelation has sparked outrage from the Scottish National Party (SNP), the Scottish Greens and anti-nuclear campaigners, who accuse the MoD of pre-empting a democratic decision. It comes on the eve of a mass ‘scrap Trident’ blockade that aims to close down Faslane on Monday.

The SNP’s defence spokesman, Angus Robertson, is writing to the Conservative Defence Minister, Michael Fallon, demanding to know what is being spent on preparing the Clyde for new Trident submarines. “The MoD has been caught out again,” he said.

“This raises some very serious questions for the MoD, as costs are being incurred before there has been any democratic scrutiny, debate or even approval,” he said. Spending money at Faslane to get ready for the next generation of Trident before a single parliamentary vote “would be completely unacceptable”, he argued.

Hundreds to risk arrest by trying to shut down Trident bomb base

from Sunday Herald, 12 April 2015

Early on Monday morning hundreds of protestors from across Scotland are planning to blockade the Faslane nuclear bomb base near Helensburgh with the aim of closing it down for the day.

Many will lock themselves together to block access roads and stop staff and military officials from getting to work. There are likely to be multiple arrests, with a major operation by Police Scotland and the Ministry of Defence expected. 

Protestors are being trained in non-violent direct action, learning passive resistance techniques, and being given legal support. If they plan on getting arrested, they are being advised to bring a sandwich to eat in the police van and a book to read in the cell.

The ‘Scrap Trident’ blockade is being organised by a coalition of 15 peace, political and pro-independence groups. It follows last Saturday’s ‘Bairns Not Bombs’ rally in Glasgow’s George Square, where up to 4,000 demonstrators were addressed by First Minister Nicola Sturgeon, Scottish Green Party co-convenor Patrick Harvie, and Labour’s North Ayrshire parliamentary candidate and former MP, Katy Clark.

Organisers say they are expecting two or three hundred people to turn up at the Trident base, and are running coaches from Glasgow and Edinburgh. Though some of the protestors will be veterans who’ve been arrested before, many will be first-timers, inspired by the independence referendum and the hope of change in the forthcoming UK election (see below).

Probe into radiation leak at Torness nuclear plant

from Sunday Herald, 29 March 2015

An investigation is under way after radiation leaked into a drain at the Torness nuclear power station in East Lothian, the Sunday Herald can reveal.

A suspect waste discharge pipe at the plant has been taken out of service, and contaminated water has had to be been removed and disposed of. Government safety watchdogs have carried out an inspection and are being kept informed of investigations.

The radiation leak was detected on 11 February and disclosed to a meeting of the Torness local liaison committee on 19 March. Though the amount of radioactivity involved is said to be small, there are growing concerns that the ageing 27-year-old nuclear plant could develop more serious problems.

According to the French state company that runs Torness, EDF Energy, radioactive tritium was discovered in water contained in sumps that are part of the site drainage system. The discovery was immediately reported to the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (Sepa) and the UK government’s Office for Nuclear Regulation (ONR).

“Subsequent checks showed that the levels of tritium found in the sump water posed no risk,” said an EDF Energy spokesman. “The water in the sumps was safely removed and disposed of via the authorised discharge routes. The sumps are sealed, preventing an unauthorised discharge to the environment.”

MoD reprimanded after radiation incident at Faslane

from The National, 23 March 2015 

The Ministry of Defence (MoD) is being reprimanded by a government watchdog for breaking safety rules after a worker was exposed to radiation at the Faslane nuclear base on the Clyde.

The incident occurred because staff stopped carrying portable alarms as they should to alert them to radiation dangers. The Office for Nuclear Regulation (ONR) is warning the MoD that it must take remedial action to make sure it doesn’t happen again.

Critics described the incident as “unacceptable” and “worrying”, arguing that it raised renewed questions about nuclear safety on the Clyde. The MoD, however, said that procedures had been improved.

The incident is described in ONR’s latest quarterly report on the Clyde nuclear submarine and bomb bases at Faslane and Coulport, posted online. It happened in June 2014, and prompted an internal investigation by the MoD and then another by ONR safety inspectors.

The worker was subjected to a small burst of radiation from a radioactive source, which had been left partially unshielded. A variety of radiation sources are used in industry as x-rays and gauges.

Pegasus grounded: vital Trident bomb project ‘on hold’ after problems

from Sunday Herald, 08 March 2015

A top-secret £634 million project vital for renewing the Trident nuclear weapons system has been halted following design and management difficulties, according to the government's Office for Nuclear Regulation (ONR).

This could undermine the UK government’s entire plan to replace Trident, say critics. They are demanding investigations by the National Audit Office and by the Ministry of Defence (MoD).

The MoD insisted that work towards replacing Trident was continuing, though it was being kept “under close review”. Insiders, however, have claimed that key projects are faltering and could be cancelled.

Since 2013 the private consortium that runs the Atomic Weapons Establishment (AWE) for the MoD has been building a plant, codenamed Pegasus, to make enriched uranium components for nuclear warheads and fuel for nuclear submarines based on the Clyde.

But in response to a freedom of information request, ONR has revealed that Pegasus - named after a fabled flying horse - has been grounded. “AWE has placed the Pegasus project on-hold and is currently re-assessing requirements for project delivery”, said ONR. A “revised scope and delivery schedule” was now awaited.

Internal documents released by ONR show that Pegasus had been “subject to a large number of changes from the start”. There had been problems with “senior management churn”, “poor engagement” and “email ping-pong” at AWE.

There had been a “reluctance of AWE staff to talk with ONR”, according to the minute of a special meeting to discuss delays in 2013. Safety reports needed to be “of better quality”, it said, and the regulatory process for Pegasus had started late and taken “longer than planned”.

ONR also expressed specific concern about one issue, though its description has been blacked out so it’s unclear what it was. “So much had to be taken on trust and any vagueness caused great difficulties with permissioning,” it said. 

MoD struggling with shortage of engineers to keep nuclear bombs safe

from Sunday Herald, 08 March 2015

The Ministry of Defence (MoD) is struggling to recruit enough skilled engineers to keep its nuclear bombs and submarines safe, according to a new report from its internal watchdog.

The Defence Nuclear Safety Regulator (DNSR) is warning that the shortage of suitably qualified nuclear staff is “the principal threat to the maintenance of safety in the Defence Nuclear Programme”. This is “a long standing issue” that could impede major developments, it says.

The warnings come in DNSR’s latest annual report covering 2013-14, which was posted online without announcement. The staff shortages have been caused by competition from the nuclear power industry, which the UK government is trying to greatly expand.

“Pressure from the civil nuclear market will continue to drive vulnerability in this small and highly skilled group,” the report says. The sustainability of the necessary skill set within the MoD “remains fragile”. 

Interventions to try and tackle the shortages had so far shown “little direct evidence of improvement”, DNSR says. “Safety has not been compromised, but the loss of resilience increases the likelihood of project delays.”

Nuclear safety incidents at Clyde bomb bases rocket

from Sunday Herald, 01 March 2015 

Fresh alarms over nuclear dangers on the Clyde have been sounded after the Ministry of Defence (MoD) revealed that the number of radiation safety incidents had leapt by more than 50 per cent in a year. 

There were 105 “nuclear safety events” officially recorded at the Faslane and Coulport submarine and bomb bases in 2013-14, compared to 68 in 2012-13. That’s by far the highest for at least the last six years (see table below).

Most of the incidents last year – 99 – involved the reactors that power Trident and other Royal Navy submarines. The remaining six involved nuclear weapons, which are carried by Trident submarines and stored at Coulport.

The MoD has not given details of all the incidents, but it stresses that they were minor and didn’t endanger the health of workers or the public. Forty-five of the events in 2013-14 were categorised as level C, meaning there was “moderate potential for future release or exposure, or localised release within a designated radiological controlled area.”

The other 60 incidents were classified as level D. This is defined by the MoD as “low potential for release – but may contribute towards an adverse trend producing latent conditions.”

Hunterston nuclear reactor closed due to faulty valve

Exclusive, 20 January 2015

One of Scotland's nuclear reactors had to be unexpectedly shut down on Christmas Day because of a faulty valve, its operator has said.

In a letter to stakeholders yesterday, EDF Energy disclosed that reactor number 4 at the Hunterston B nuclear power station in North Ayrshire was taken offline just after 11am on 25 December "after an issue with a pneumatic valve when its air supply line failed".

"We decided to shut down the unit so we could carry out repairs and it was brought back into service on Sunday 28 December 2014 at 17.30," said the station director, Colin Weir.

Hunterston B comprises two nuclear reactors, numbered three and four, which can each provide up to 500 megawatts of electricity to the national grid. It is one of Scotland's two working nuclear power stations, the other being at Torness in East Lothian.

A copy of the letter to stakeholders from EDF Energy on 19 January 2015 is available to download here (229KB pdf).